Show/Hide Toolbars

HOMER Pro 3.9

Navigation: Results > Simulation Results

Compare Economics

Scroll Prev Top Next More


To open the Compare Economics tab, double-click a system in the Optimization Results table. Click Compare Economics tab on the Simulation Results window. This tab allows you to compare the economic merits of the current system and a base case system. The window displays cash flow graphs and a table of economic metrics.


The Compare Economics button can be accessed from the top right part of the results page (highlighted in yellow below). This opens up a pop up window with a list of categorized and overall simulations. You need to choose the base case to compare all other simulations to.


You must choose a base case system to compare with the current system to make the economic metrics meaningful. The metrics show you the value of the difference between two options, taking into account the life-cycle costs of both systems. You can compare the current system to any other system in the optimization results. For example:

Compare a PV-wind-diesel hybrid system with a diesel-only base case system for an off-grid project to find the present worth of fuel saved by installing a hybrid system instead of a diesel-only system, taking into account the cost of installing, operating, and maintaining each system.

Compare a grid-connected PV system to a grid-only system to find the payback period required for grid sales to recover the cost of installing the PV system.

The table at the top of the window displays a list of systems from the optimization results from which you can choose a base case. You can display the list as a categorized list to display only the top-ranked system in each category, or as an overall list to display all systems.

The system summary table shows the component sizes, capital cost, and net present cost of the base case system and current system.

The display options control what appears in the cash flow graph.

Tip: Click and drag or click and press Ctrl+A to select the table. Then press Ctrl+C to copy the data to your clipboard. You can then paste the data into another program like Microsoft Excel or MATLAB.

Once you have selected the base case, your results include a new section called Compare Economics. The base is highlighted in green. The other cases have a IRR and Simple Payback (yr) to show how they fare against the base case selected.


Another way to see the result of compare economics is to double click a simulation and go to the Compare Economics tab in the pop up window.


When you choose a base case system, the metric table shows economic measures representing the value of the difference between the two systems:

The present worth is the difference between the net present costs of the base case system and the current system. The sign of the present worth indicates whether the current system compares favorably as an investment option with the base case system: A positive value indicates that the current system saves money over the project lifetime compared to the base case system.

The annual worth is the present worth multiplied by the capital recovery factor.

To see how HOMER calculates return on investment (ROI), choose the following display options: Graph, Difference, Cumulative. Subtract the cumulative nominal cash flow in year zero from the cumulative nominal cash flow in the final year. Divide that number by the lifetime and then again by the cumulative nominal cash flow in year zero. Note that the cumulative nominal cash flow in year zero is equivalent to the base case capital cost minus the current system capital cost.

Internal rate of return (IRR) is the discount rate at which the base case and current system have the same net present cost. HOMER calculates the IRR by determining the discount rate that makes the present value of the difference of the two cash flow sequences equal to zero.

Payback is the number of years at which the cumulative cash flow of the difference between the current system and base case system switches from negative to positive. The payback is an indication of how long it would take to recover the difference in investment costs between the current system and the base case system. You can see a visual representation of the payback by choosing the following display options: Graph, Difference, and Cumulative. The simple payback is where the nominal cash flow difference line crosses zero. The discounted payback is where the discounted cash flow difference line crosses zero.